Can We Talk About The Fandom Divide On Bobby, Like Half The Fandom Is Convinced He Killed His Band Mates,

Can we talk about the fandom divide on Bobby, like half the fandom is convinced he killed his band mates, and the other half loves him, and he's their favorite character. They really gave us a blank slate and the fandom just wrote in their own version of him, and I love it.

Why is Charlie/Luke wearing red socks in perfect harmony??? I dont get it, was it a mistake!?!? If it was done intentionally can someone explain to me why they had him in red socks.

(Also this is in no way meant to be seen as me bashing the show, or Charlie Gillespie, I am very much obsessed with both of them)

Fair warning any and all post I make for the foreseeable future will be either Captain America and The Winter Soldier(White Wolf), or Shadow and Bone/Six of crows related

Crimson Rivers chapter 40 spoilers

Something that makes me sad is that Regulus didn't think he was worth enough for Effie to volunteer for him. She stated explicitly that she would volunteer for whoever name got called, and Zar has stated that her plan was to volunteer for whoever was called first. But regulus said that sirius wasn't supposed to volunteer for him, so that it would be him and Effie going in. He didn't realize that if sirius hadn't volunteered for him then Effie would have. He didn't think he was included in Effies plan to save them.

Ok so I dont know if this has been talked about already or is already considered cannon, but I have a theory for why Julie being able to touch them got rid of Caleb's stamp. So we already "know" that the reason Julie can touch the Phantoms is because she's part of their souls, but that still doesn't really explain how it got rid of the stamp. So the stamp allows Caleb to own the phantoms souls, but when Julie becomes part of their souls this is no longer possible. Caleb can not own Julie or her soul, therefore a part of the boys' souls are off limit to him, causing his hold on them to be relinquished. This would also explain why he's now trying to get to Julie(through Nick), Caleb can't control the boys until he controls Julie

🚨Crimson rivers chapter 44 and 45 spoilers🚨

Maybe I'm just too trusting but I dont/didn't think for a second that Regulus is joining the death eaters for self preservation/to kill Sirius. Do I have any clue what his plan is? Absolutely not. Do I trust that he has one? 100% that man is a liar and has no plans to kill Sirus, and I am here for his lies and deciet.